The Foundry Cyber blog

What to expect from a cyber security provider, and what to ask before you sign

· 4 min read

Buying cyber security as a small business is awkward. You’re being asked to judge the quality of work you can’t see, in a field with its own vocabulary, from people who know far more about it than you do. That’s a difficult position to buy from.

You don’t need to understand the technology to choose well. You need to ask ordinary questions and listen to how they’re answered. These are the eight we’d ask.

1. Who actually does the work?

Find out whether the person you’re speaking to will be the person doing the work, and if not, who will. Ask about their experience. There’s nothing wrong with a salesperson or an account manager, but you should know whose hands are on your systems.

A good answer names someone, or describes the team honestly, including its size.

2. What access do you need, and can I take it away?

Any security company needs some access to check anything. What matters is how much, and who controls it.

A good answer is specific. Read-only where that’s enough. Named accounts for each person, never one shared login. Clear instructions for removing the access yourself, without having to ask.

3. What will I get, and can I see an example?

“A report” isn’t an answer. Ask to see one, with another customer’s details removed or with made-up data.

A good answer is a sample you can read and understand. If the example is a long export from a tool, with no explanation of what matters most, that’s what you’ll be paying for.

4. What’s included, and what costs extra?

This is where most disappointment starts. A monthly fee might cover checking and reporting but not fixing. It might cover fixing up to a limit. It might cover a helpdesk, or it might not.

A good answer separates four things plainly: what they check, what they fix, what they keep managing, and what’s charged on top. If you can’t draw that line after the conversation, ask again.

5. How will I know the work is being done?

With most services, you can see the result. With security, when it’s going well, nothing happens. That makes it easy to pay for a year of nothing and not know.

A good answer gives you something you can look at whenever you like: what was checked, when, what was found and what’s been done about it.

6. How long am I tied in?

Some commitment is normal. Ongoing security work only makes sense over months. But you should know the length before you sign, along with what happens at the end and what happens if you want to leave early.

A good answer states the term in a sentence and doesn’t bury it.

7. Will you work with the people I already have?

If you have an IT company, a web developer or someone in the office who looks after the computers, a new provider should fit round them.

A good answer explains who would do what. Be wary of anyone whose first suggestion is to replace everything and everyone.

8. What don’t you do?

Our favourite question, because it’s the hardest to answer badly. Nobody does everything well.

A good answer is a short, definite list. “We don’t do that, and here’s the kind of firm that does” is a sign you’re dealing with someone straightforward.

Warning signs

A few things should make you slow down, whoever is saying them.

None of these proves a company is bad. They’re reasons to ask one more question.

Our own answers

It would be odd to publish this list and not answer it ourselves.

  1. Who does the work? You deal with the engineer who does it. We’re a small company, and we say so.
  2. Access? Read-only by default, under named identities, with the least access the job needs. You can remove it yourself. How we connect.
  3. What do you get? Findings in plain English, ranked by what matters. There’s an illustrative example on our homepage.
  4. Included and extra? A one-off job is quoted before we start. Ongoing plans cover scheduled checks, findings and reports. Fix work is quoted separately. It’s set out side by side on our services page.
  5. How will you know? Customers on an ongoing plan get their own portal showing what was checked, what was found and what’s been fixed.
  6. Tied in? Ongoing plans run for 12 months. One-off jobs have no term.
  7. Working with others? Yes. We work alongside your IT company, not in place of them.
  8. What don’t we do? We’re not a helpdesk. We don’t fix printers or run day-to-day IT support, we don’t offer round-the-clock monitoring, and we don’t issue Cyber Essentials certificates, though we’ll get you ready for one.

If those answers suit you, get in touch. If they don’t, the eight questions will serve you just as well with someone else.

All posts

Onboarding new customers now

Not sure where to start? That's fine.

Tell us a little about your business and what you need help with. We'll tell you what we'd recommend, and whether we're the right people for the job.