What's in a Microsoft 365 security check?
· 4 min read
“Security assessment” is one of those phrases that can mean almost anything. It might be a questionnaire, a two-hundred-page export from a scanning tool, or a person spending real time understanding how your business is set up. They don’t cost the same and they aren’t worth the same.
So here’s what a check of a small business’s Microsoft 365 should involve, what you should expect to hold at the end, and how to tell a useful one from an expensive PDF. We’ll describe how we do it, but the tests at the bottom apply to anyone you might ask.
What it is, and what it isn’t
A Microsoft 365 security check looks at how your account is configured: who has access to what, and which protections are switched on.
It isn’t a penetration test. Nobody is trying to break in. It isn’t a certificate either. A check can tell you how close you are to something like Cyber Essentials, but the certificate itself comes from a certification body after a separate process.
It’s done with read-only access. We can look at settings and can’t change them. You approve that access, and you can take it away again.
What gets looked at
The full list is long. These are the areas that matter most in a small business, roughly in the order they cause trouble.
Who has the keys. How many people have administrator rights, whether they need them, and whether those accounts are used for everyday email. Admin accounts are the ones worth stealing.
Sign-in protection. Whether every account needs a second step to sign in. Not most accounts. All of them, including shared mailboxes, service accounts and the one that was set up in a hurry.
Accounts that shouldn’t be there. People who’ve left, contractors whose project finished, guests from other companies, and test accounts nobody remembers creating. There’s a checklist for this in what should happen when someone leaves.
What’s shared outside. Files and folders open to anyone with the link, and external guests who can still see more than they need to.
Email. Whether your domain can be faked, whether the phishing protections in your plan are switched on, and whether any mailbox is quietly forwarding its contents somewhere else. A forwarding rule nobody set up is one of the clearest signs that an account has been taken over.
Devices. Whether the laptops and phones that hold your data are encrypted, kept up to date, and can be wiped if they’re lost.
Records. Whether audit logging is on, so that if something does happen, there’s something to look at.
What your plan allows. Some protections only exist on certain Microsoft 365 plans. A good check tells you which gaps can be fixed with what you already pay for and which would need something more. We’ve covered the differences in Basic, Standard or Premium.
What you should get at the end
Not a spreadsheet of four hundred rows. A short document that a director can read in ten minutes and that says, for each problem:
- What’s wrong, in plain English
- Why it matters to a business like yours
- How serious it is compared with the others
- What to do about it
And, above all, an order. Most small businesses have a few things that need doing this week and a longer list that can wait. If everything is marked urgent, nothing is.
You should also be able to ask questions about it, and get answers from the person who did the work.
What it can’t tell you
It’s worth being honest about the limits.
- It checks settings, not behaviour. It can tell you that multi-factor authentication is on. It can’t tell you whether someone will approve a sign-in request they didn’t make.
- It covers what you asked to be checked. If your accounts software, your website or your phone system sit outside Microsoft 365, they need their own look.
- It’s a picture of one day. People join and leave, apps get connected, settings get changed to fix a problem and never changed back. A clean check in January tells you little about September.
That last point is why some businesses choose to have the check repeated on a schedule. It’s also why a check on its own doesn’t make anything secure. The value is in what gets fixed afterwards.
What happens next is up to you
Once you have the findings, there are three sensible routes, and they can be mixed:
- Fix it yourselves. Some items are a single setting. A good report tells you which.
- Hand it to your IT company. If you have one, the report gives them a clear list. More on that in we have an IT company, who checks our security?
- Ask whoever did the check to fix it. In our case that’s quoted separately, item by item, so you only pay for what you want done.
Nobody should make the check conditional on buying the fixes.
Five questions for judging any assessment
Before you pay for one, from us or anyone else, ask:
- Can I see an example of what I’ll get?
- Who does the work, and can I speak to them afterwards?
- What access do you need, and how do I remove it?
- Will the findings be ranked, or just listed?
- What does it cost, and what happens after?
If the answers are clear, you’re probably in good hands.
How ours works
Ours is a fixed price, agreed before we start. You get a short, ranked report in plain English, and you can stop there. There’s more on what we check and fix, or you can ask us to check yours.