We have an IT company. Who checks our security?
· 3 min read
A lot of small businesses have an IT company they’re happy with. The laptops work, the email works, and when something breaks, someone picks up the phone. Then a customer sends a security questionnaire, or an insurer asks about multi-factor authentication, and a thought arrives that hadn’t come up before: who actually checks this?
It’s a fair question, and it isn’t a criticism of your IT company.
Two different jobs
IT support is about keeping things working. A good provider is judged on how quickly problems get fixed and how rarely they happen. That’s exactly what you want from them.
Security is about what could go wrong. And the awkward thing about an insecure setting is that it causes no problems at all. Nothing breaks when a former employee’s account is left open. No ticket gets raised because five people have full admin rights. Everything works perfectly, right up until the day it’s used against you.
So the things support is measured on and the things security cares about don’t overlap as much as you’d expect. A provider can be doing an excellent job at the first without anyone having asked them to do the second.
There’s also a simpler point. It’s hard to check your own work. That’s not a comment on anyone’s competence. It’s why accounts are audited by someone who didn’t prepare them.
What’s usually in the contract
Have a look at what you’re paying for. Most support agreements cover things like:
- A helpdesk
- Setting up new starters
- Looking after laptops, printers and Wi-Fi
- Licences and renewals
- Backups, sometimes
What’s often not there is a regular, structured review of how your systems are configured for security. If it isn’t written down, it’s reasonable to assume it isn’t happening. That doesn’t mean it’s being neglected on purpose. It means nobody has asked for it or paid for it.
Seven questions worth asking
These aren’t trick questions, and a good IT company will be glad you asked.
- Who has administrator access to our systems, including your own staff?
- Does every account have multi-factor authentication, including the shared mailboxes and the admin accounts?
- When you log in to our systems, do your engineers use their own named accounts, or one shared login?
- What happens when someone leaves us? Who tells you, and what do you close?
- When were our security settings last reviewed from top to bottom, and is there anything written down?
- Is our email domain protected against being faked? (There’s a plain-English explanation in can someone send email pretending to be you?)
- Is a security review part of what we pay you for?
What good answers sound like
Good answers are specific. “Three people here have admin access, and I can send you their names.” “We reviewed it in March, and here’s the list of what we changed.” “Leavers aren’t in our process at the moment, because you’d need to tell us. Shall we set that up?”
Vague answers aren’t proof of a problem. They’re a sign that it’s been a while since anyone looked. “It’s all fine” and “you’re covered” are the ones to follow up, politely, with “could you show me?”
And if the answer to question seven is “no, that isn’t in the agreement”, that’s an honest answer. It tells you where the gap is.
What a second pair of eyes looks like
This is where a company like ours fits. We don’t do IT support, and we don’t want your IT company’s job.
In practice it works like this:
- We’re given read-only access, so we can look and can’t change anything.
- We check how your Microsoft 365, email and website are set up.
- We write up what we find in plain English and share it with you and with your IT company.
- Together you decide who fixes what. Some providers prefer to make the changes themselves. Others are happy to hand the security work over.
- If you want, we check again on a schedule, so the picture stays current.
A good IT company will usually welcome it. It gives them a list they can act on, and a reason to have a conversation with their customer that’s hard to start on their own.
The short version
Having an IT company and having someone check your security aren’t the same thing, and wanting both isn’t disloyal. Keep the people who keep you running. Ask them the seven questions. And if the answers leave you unsure, get someone independent to take a look.
That’s what we do. There’s more about working alongside your IT company on our site, or you can get in touch and we’ll talk it through.