The Foundry Cyber blog

Why your website matters more than you think, and whether to fix it or start again

· 5 min read

Over the last four weeks we’ve looked at what goes wrong on older websites: software that drifts out of date, cookie banners that don’t do anything, contact forms that hoard personal data and missing legal details.

It’s fair to ask whether any of this really matters for a small business with a five-page website. This last post answers that, and then helps you decide what to do about it.

Why it matters

It’s the part of your business everyone can see

Your website is the one part of your business that anyone in the world can look at, any time, without asking. That includes customers, but it also includes the automated tools that scan the internet looking for weaknesses. Those tools don’t care how big you are. They just find the sites that are easiest to get into.

For a lot of small businesses, the website is the most exposed thing they own and the least looked after.

You’re responsible for it, even if someone else built it

This is the point that surprises people most. Under UK GDPR, if your website collects personal data, your business is responsible for it. That’s true whether you built the site yourself, paid an agency in 2018, or got a favour from a friend.

If the site is broken into and customer details are taken, it’s your business that may need to report it to the ICO, tell your customers and explain what went wrong. “The web designer said it was fine” won’t change that.

Other people check

More and more, the businesses you work with want to know how you look after data. Bigger customers send supplier security questionnaires. Insurers ask about how you keep systems up to date. Some contracts ask for Cyber Essentials.

Your website is often the first thing they look at. It’s hard to give confident answers about your security when your homepage shows a “Not secure” warning or a copyright date from 2019.

The rules have caught up

This year has seen the biggest change to UK data protection law in years. Cookie fines now match UK GDPR. Businesses need a proper way to handle data protection complaints. The ICO has new powers to investigate. A small business is still far more likely to get a warning than a fine, but the days of nobody paying attention are over.

The knock-on effects

When a small business website is compromised, the damage usually isn’t dramatic. It’s slow and annoying. Visitors get redirected to scam pages, often only on phones, so you don’t notice for weeks. Search engines start warning people away. Your server gets used to send spam, and your normal emails start landing in junk folders. Each one costs you enquiries, and fixing it costs time you don’t have.

What a good small business website looks like now

A modern, well-looked-after site isn’t complicated. It:

Fix it, or start again?

Once you know what’s wrong, the next question is whether to repair your current site or replace it. There’s no single right answer, but these questions usually make it clear.

Fixing usually makes sense if:

Starting again usually makes sense if:

That third point deserves a bit more explanation. Most small business websites are brochures. They change a few times a year. Yet many run on systems designed for publishing new content every day, which means a server, a database and a stack of plugins that all need updating, forever.

For a brochure site, there’s often a simpler option: a static website. It looks the same to your visitors, but it’s made of ready-made pages with nothing running behind them. There’s no database to break into and no plugins to fall behind on. It’s fast, cheap to host and needs far less maintenance. Your contact form still works, handled by a small separate service.

It isn’t right for everyone. A busy online shop needs more. But for a lot of small businesses, rebuilding a neglected site this way can work out cheaper over a couple of years than keeping the old one patched.

Five questions to ask whoever looks after your website

Whether you fix or rebuild, these are worth asking. A good web person will have the answers ready.

  1. When was the software behind our site last updated, and is every part of it still supported?
  2. Does the site store contact form submissions? If so, how many, and for how long?
  3. What cookies and outside services does the site load, and do any of them need consent?
  4. If the site was broken into, how would we know, and what would happen next?
  5. Who is responsible for keeping all of this up to date, and how often do they check?

If the answers are vague, that tells you something.

If you want help

This is exactly the work we do. We’ll check your current website against everything in this series and give you a plain-English report: what needs fixing now, what can wait and what’s fine. If it makes more sense to start again, we can rebuild it as a fast, secure site and look after the hosting, so you don’t have to think about it again.

Either way, you’ll get a straight answer. Get in touch and tell us about your site.

This series is general information for UK businesses, not legal advice. If you’re unsure how something applies to you, speak to a solicitor or check the ICO’s guidance for small organisations.

All posts

Onboarding new customers now

Not sure where to start? That's fine.

Tell us a little about your business and what you need help with. We'll tell you what we'd recommend, and whether we're the right people for the job.